Tom Gardiner joined LifeMatters on 96.1 WLKG in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin, on September 18, 2022.
What we covered
Before Illinois’ Pretrial Fairness Act (part of the SAFE-T Act) was due to end cash bail, Tom talked through why lawmakers passed it, how cash bail can keep people in jail simply because they can’t pay, and his concern that the law took discretion away from judges in serious cases. (The Illinois Supreme Court later upheld the law, and it took effect in September 2023.)
In Tom’s words
The concern was that the bond system disproportionately impacted the poor. If you’re a rich kid, the family says, here’s a million bucks. If it’s a kid whose family doesn’t have any money, that kid sits in jail.
I understand the reform element of it, but it depends on which crimes it should apply to.
I was an assistant state’s attorney in Cook County for six and a half years. What this does is take the discretion away from the judge.
I always favor giving judges discretion, because they’re the people hearing the cases. They see thousands of cases. They have some collective wisdom, and I’d rather put my faith in their collective wisdom than in the legislature.
It is so much easier to prepare your case with the client out of jail. That is a tremendous benefit from my point of view.
Quotes are lightly edited for readability. This conversation is general information, not legal advice, and reflects the law and events as of September 18, 2022. To talk with an attorney, call (312) 362-0000 in Illinois or (262) 812-0864 in Wisconsin, or send us a message.
Related: More from GKWW on 96.1 WLKG
